Turn your lessons into experiences.
Lessons students want to explore, participate in and remember.
Edugine helps tutors create and run live learning experiences where students actively participate, interact and collaborate — while tutors see what students are doing and guide the lesson in real time.
Lesson
B2ENPerformance Review English: Giving and Receiving Feedback
Practice softening language and constructive feedback phrases through realistic performance review simulations. Give tough feedback without destroying someone's confidence, receive criticism without getting defensive, and navigate the conversation both sides dread. A practical B2 English lesson on diplomatic language, feedback vocabulary, and professional one-to-one conversations. Ideal for adult learners, English tutors, and language schools.
How this lesson works
Students participate
Students interact directly with the lesson — responding, speaking, solving tasks, making decisions and joining activities.
You see what is happening
See student responses, answers, mistakes and activity in real time where supported.
You guide the experience
Guide the lesson, manage activities and timing, and respond to what students are doing where supported.
Everyone participates
Students actively contribute and interact instead of simply consuming lesson content.
Spot the Problem — Real Feedback Gone Wrong. Multiple Choice
Multiple Choice
A manager says: "Your work has been disappointing lately." What is wrong with this feedback?
- Nothing — this is perfectly acceptable feedback
- It's too long and detailed
- It uses overly formal language
- It's vague — "disappointing" doesn't tell the employee what to improve
A manager says: "You need to be more like Sarah — she never makes mistakes." What is wrong?
- The manager should compare to at least three colleagues, not just one
- Comparing employees destroys trust and creates resentment
- Sarah should be in the room to confirm
- Nothing — role models are a good motivation tool
An employee receives feedback and immediately says: "That's not fair — you never noticed the good things I did." What is the problem?
- They are completely right and should continue arguing
- They should agree with everything the manager says
- They are being defensive instead of listening first and responding after
- They should leave the room immediately
A manager writes in a review: "Sometimes your attitude could perhaps be slightly better in certain situations." What is wrong?
- It's too aggressive and direct
- The word "attitude" is inappropriate in a professional context
- It's over-hedged — so many softeners that the message disappears completely
- Nothing — this is perfectly diplomatic
A manager says: "I don't have any negative feedback — you're doing great, keep it up!" What could be the problem?
- Positive feedback should never be given in a performance review
- The employee gets no information about how to grow — positive-only feedback is not helpful long-term
- Nothing — if there are no problems, there's nothing to discuss
- The manager is being too generous with compliments
An employee responds to criticism by saying: "I understand. Could you give me a specific example so I know exactly what to work on?" What is this?
- Inappropriate — employees should not ask managers for examples
- A sign of weakness — they should already know what went wrong
- An excellent response — they are listening, not defending, and asking for clarity
- Too formal for a performance review conversation
Feedback and Review Vocabulary. Speed Match
Speed Match
- Constructive feedback→Comments designed to help someone improve, not just criticise
- Defensive→Reacting to criticism by protecting yourself instead of listening
- Strengths→The skills and qualities a person does well
- Areas for improvement→Polite way of describing weaknesses or things to work on
- Self-assessment→Evaluating your own performance before the review meeting
- KPI→Key Performance Indicator — a measurable target used to evaluate success
- Objective→A specific, measurable goal set for an employee to achieve
- Development plan→A structured plan for building new skills over a set period
- Probation→A trial period where a new employee's performance is closely monitored
- Appraisal→A formal evaluation of an employee's work over a specific period
- 360 feedback→Feedback collected from managers, peers, and direct reports
- Recognition→Publicly or privately acknowledging someone's good work
Lesson Board
Lesson Board
Say It Diplomatically. Word Choice
Word Choice
- I've noticedknownseen that deadlines have been a challenge for you recently.
- There ishasseems to be some room for improvement in how you handle client emails.
- It mustmightshould be worth exploring a different approach to time management.
- Your technical skills are strong, howeverandbut your communication with the team could be better.
- I'd like to suggestforcedemand a development plan to help you build on your strengths.
- From time to time, your reports have been extremelyverysomewhat less detailed than we'd expect.
- I likewantappreciate you raising this — can we discuss how I can improve?
- Could you saytellgive me a specific example so I understand exactly what you mean?
- One failureproblemarea for improvement would be how you prioritise tasks when multiple deadlines overlap.
- I think your workscontributionsdoings this year have been excellent, especially the client retention project.
The Performance Review. Roleplay Quest
Roleplay Quest
Scenario
It is annual review time. A manager and an employee are sitting down for a 45-minute one-to-one conversation. The manager has positive things to say — but also one serious concern that must be addressed. The employee thinks they've had a great year and is expecting praise. Use softening language from the Lesson Board. The conversation should feel real — not scripted.
The Manager
You manage a team of 8. This employee is talented and likeable — the team loves them. Their creative work is excellent. But they have missed 4 deadlines this quarter, and two clients have complained about late deliveries. You must address this without destroying their motivation.
Secret goal: Use the sandwich approach: start with genuine praise, then raise the deadline issue with specific examples, then end with a development plan. Use softening language: "I've noticed...", "There seems to be...", "It might help to..." If the employee gets defensive, stay calm and redirect: "I understand how you feel — let's focus on how we move forward."
The Employee — High Performer
You believe you've had your best year ever. You redesigned the company website, won a design award, and mentored two junior colleagues. You expect a glowing review and possibly a promotion.
Secret goal: You have no idea the manager has concerns. When you hear criticism, your first instinct is to defend yourself: "But I stayed late every night!" / "Nobody told me the deadline was firm!" If the manager uses specific examples, you will gradually accept the feedback — but only if they acknowledge your strengths first. If they lead with criticism, you will shut down.
The Manager — First Time
This is your first time conducting a performance review. You have notes but you are nervous. Your employee is more experienced than you and you find them slightly intimidating.
Secret goal: You have clear feedback to give: strong technical skills but poor communication with other departments. Three colleagues have complained that this person doesn't respond to emails for days. You know the feedback is valid but you are worried about the confrontation. You tend to over-soften and say things like "maybe, possibly, slightly" until your message disappears.
The Employee — Struggling
You know this hasn't been your best year. Personal problems affected your focus. You missed targets, your energy was low, and you avoided difficult conversations. You haven't told anyone at work what's going on.
Secret goal: You are expecting a bad review. If the manager is kind and asks how you're doing, you might open up. If they go straight to criticism, you will agree with everything quietly and say "I'll try harder" without meaning it. What you actually need is someone to ask: "Is everything okay?" — not more KPI targets.
The Review Goes Sideways. Drama Event
Drama Event
Scenario
The performance review is underway. It started well. But these conversations have a way of going places nobody planned...
- 🎲
wordlist
I didn't expect to hear that — can we pause for a moment? I think we're getting off track — let's come back to the main point. I hear what you're saying, and I want to respond honestly. That's not how I intended it — let me rephrase. I need a moment to process this before I respond. Can we talk about what a realistic plan would look like? I want to be fair — so let me share what I've also observed. Thank you for being honest with me.
- 🧠
Revelation
The employee says: "Before we continue, there's something I need to tell you. I've been interviewing at another company. I haven't accepted anything yet — but the reason I'm looking is because I don't feel valued here." The manager didn't see this coming.
- ⏱
Pressure
The employee asks directly: "Am I getting a promotion this year? Because if the answer is no, I need to know why — and I need to know what exactly I have to do to get one." The manager has no authority to promise a promotion.
- 🔄
Twist
The manager gives feedback about poor teamwork. The employee responds: "That's interesting, because three people on the team told me privately that YOU are the reason collaboration is difficult. They said you micromanage and don't listen." The room goes silent.
- 🧨
Crisis
The employee starts crying. Not dramatically — just quietly, eyes filling. They say: "I'm sorry. It's been a really hard year outside of work and I thought I was hiding it better." The manager has no training in handling this.
- 🎯
Decision
The employee says: "I accept all your feedback. But I want something in return: a mentor, a flexible schedule for three months, and a clear path to promotion. If the company can't offer that, I'll take the other job offer. What can you do?"
- 🚧
Constraint
The manager realises halfway through the review that their own manager gave them incorrect data. The "missed deadlines" were actually caused by another department's delays, not this employee. Do they admit the mistake now or finish the review and correct it later?
- 🧭
Opportunity
The employee shares an idea they've been developing privately — a new process that could save the company significant time and money. They say: "I didn't bring it up before because I didn't think anyone would listen." This changes the tone of the entire conversation.
- 🔄
Twist
After 20 minutes of difficult feedback, the employee says calmly: "I've been recording this conversation on my phone. I want to make sure there's an accurate record of what was said." Is this legal? Is it ethical? How does the manager react?
- 🎲
settings
- 🎲
settings
- 🎲
settings
Write Your Own Feedback. Word Cards
Word Cards
- Your colleague gives great presentations but interrupts people constantly in meetings.|Write one sentence of constructive feedback using softening language.
- Your team member is technically brilliant but impossible to work with — they refuse to compromise.|Give feedback that addresses the behaviour without attacking the person.
- You are the employee. Your manager just told you that your work is "not meeting expectations."|Write a response that is professional, not defensive, and asks for specifics.
- Your direct report has improved dramatically in the last 3 months after a bad start.|Write feedback that recognises the improvement without ignoring the earlier problems.
- You must tell a long-term employee that their role is being made redundant — it's not about performance.|Find the words that are honest, respectful, and clear.
- A colleague asks you informally: "How do you think I'm doing?" You have concerns but this isn't the right moment.|What do you say now, and what do you suggest for later?
Why Edugine?
Turn your lessons into experiences.
Edugine helps tutors create and run live learning experiences where students actively participate, interact and collaborate — while tutors see what students are doing and guide the lesson in real time.